The American Hotel
March 1st, 2010



It usually starts with soup. Every season, new visitors undertake the pilgrimage to the American Hotel in Lima fueled by reverential recommendations for one or more of over 60+ varieties. Rose Reynold’s flavorful repertoire includes the standards (Beef Barley, Split Pea, French Onion, Corn Chowder), as well as slightly more upscale offerings (Butternut & Apple Bisque, Sweet Potato & Leek, Dijon Beef). But the real counterpoints to the traditional setting are offbeat entries like Banana Bisque, Lentil & Franks, Double Squash with Pesto, and Cold Blueberry. Then there’s Cheeseburger Chowder, a perennial customer favorite that third generation co-owner Pat Reynolds describes simply as “everything but the bun.” Call ahead to find out which varieties will be featured on any given day.
Rose’s soup makes a fine meal alone, or accompanied by a grilled pretzel roll. And there’s also a selection of sandwiches (including fried baloney or Limburger cheese), plus spiedies, burgers, and dogs. The atmosphere is grand aging pub (the bar serves over 30 varieties of beer), and there is much to discover throughout, including back-room murals (ask for the story), an original wood telephone box, and overnight accommodations at the top of the weathered staircase. The ambiance is particularly magical during December, when the rooms are lovingly outfitted in vintage holiday style.
The American Hotel is decidedly homespun. Yet the sense of comfort you’ll experience is not confined to the food or fixtures. The place is also richly animated by the stories of its owners, employees, and patrons, both past and present. Photos and newspaper articles stud the faded walls, and Pat and Rose serve up additional tidbits as they watchfully tend kitchen and bar. If it’s quiet, ask to meet Bridget, the celebrity lab-in-residence. And remember to save room for the fresh little cookie that will sweeten your already reasonable bill.
Vegetarian and gluten-free options available.
Soup: $3.50 - $4.50
Sandwiches: $3.75 - $6.75
American Hotel
7304 East Main Street
Lima, NY 14485
585-624-9464


























